No Bake Peppermint Icebox Pie

Jump to Recipe

One of my favorite things about the holidays is peppermint! I love peppermint ice cream, peppermint patties, and definitely this No Bake Peppermint Icebox Pie!

Half a no bake peppermint icebox pie in a pie plate with peppermint candies in the other half with a slice of peppermint pie on a silver plate all on a red striped background.

I just love no bake pies, and this is one of my absolute favorite desserts to eat during the holidays.

Table of Contents

What do you need to make this No Bake Peppermint Icebox Pie?

You will need a few things:

25 OREO cookies
salt
butter
cream cheese, marshmallow creme
peppermint extract
powdered sugar
heavy cream
crushed soft peppermints
red food coloring

How do you make the No Bake Peppermint Icebox Pie?

First, we’ll start with the crust. Begin by melting the butter.

Add the OREO cookies to a food processor or blender and add the salt and melted butter. You can use salted butter and skip the additional salt.

A chocolate OREO cookie crust in a pie plate.

Then, press the cookie mixture into the pie pan. I find using the back of a measuring cup to press it, is really helpful.

Cream cheese and whipped cream mixed together with beaters.

Then it’s time to move onto the filling. First, using an electric mixer, beat the cream cheese until fluffy and then add the marshmallow creme and peppermint extract.

In another bowl beat the heavy cream and sugar until it’s forms stiff peaks.

Swirls of red and white peppermint flavored filling for the pie.

Combine the two mixture and gently fold together as you add the food coloring. Don’t add too much food coloring to just make a pink color.

The pink peppermint pie filling in the chocolate cookie crust in the pie plate.

Spoon the mixture into the crust and refrigerate for at least 4 hours, preferably overnight.

The pie topped with sweetened whipped cream.

When it’s fairly close to serving time, whip the rest of the cream and sugar until soft peaks form and spoon it over the top of the peppermint mixture.

The no bake peppermint icebox pie finished and topped with crushed peppermints.

Finish off with a sprinkle of crushed peppermint

Serve and enjoy!

A slice of no bake pappermint icebox pie on a marble table.

More Peppermint Recipes

More Holiday Dessert Recipes

12 servings