This shop has been compensated by Collective Bias, Inc. and its advertiser. All opinions are mine alone.
Every Christmas Eve, we make something for Santa like decorating sugar cookies or whipping up something simple like marshmallow cereal treats. The kids love to make something new and special for Santa. We always write a little note for him and leave carrots for the reindeer. And, Santa usually writes us back when he eats our snacks!
This year we will be making some Nilla Fluffernutter sandwiches with NILLA Wafers, Peter Pan Simply Ground™, and marshmallow creme that will be dipped in chocolate for a decadent treat! We can’t forget a nice hot drink like some Swiss Miss® hot cocoa. We found everything we needed right at Walmart. Make sure you click the banner below to get an Ibotta rebate for all of it!
These little cookie sandwiches are so easy to make, the kids can do it. Here’s all you need to do:
We make a dozen at a time, so I have my 6 year old count out 24 NILLA Wafers.
Then, put Peter Pan Simply Ground™ on 12 of them. My kids love it because it’s creamy with a bit of crunch to it. Next, put marshmallow creme on the other 12.
Then, it’s time to put one peanut butter side and one marshmallow side together to form little sandwiches.
Next, I melt a bar of chocolate in the microwave for 30 seconds, then stir. Then, I microwave an additional 20 seconds so that it’s evenly melted and stir.
Lay out a piece of wax paper or parchment paper on a cookie sheet that will fit in the freezer, and then start dipping your little sandwiches!
Dip half of each cookie sandwich in the chocolate, let it drip off the extra, and then place it on the cookie sheet. Once you’ve finished, put them in the freezer for 10-15 minutes to harden the chocolate.
Print
Nilla Fluffernutter Sandwiches for Santa
Ingredients
- 24 NILLA Wafers
- Peter Pan Simply Ground
- marshmallow creme
- 1 chocolate bar
Instructions
- Smear 12 NILLA Wafers with peanut butter.
- Smear the other 12 Nilla Wafers with marshmallow creme.
- Put them together.
- Melt a bar of chocolate for 30 seconds, then stir. Melt an additional 20-30 seconds as needed to melted it completely.
- Dip each Nilla Fluffernutter sandwich halfway into the chocolate.
- Set each one on wax paper or parchment paper on a cookie sheet.
- Freeze for 10-15 minutes to harden the chocolate.
- Serve immediately!
Fix Santa a cup of Swiss Miss hot cocoa along with a plate of Nilla Fluffernutter sandwiches. Let the kids write him a note and make sure you leave the reindeer some carrots!
Ready to make Santa an easy sweet treat? Check out some other great ideas and don’t forget to grab the Ibotta rebates for all of these products!
20 comments
Those look so good! Anything that uses Nilla wafers is always a winner in my book. I can’t wait to make these.
The sandwiches looks so yummy and great combination with the swiss miss.. Thank you for sharing your recipe.
These look super tasty and I know that Santa would love to find these under the tree this Christmas Eve. I am going to need to pick up these ingredients this week.
These look so yummy! They seem easy enough that I could make them!
Silvia
http://www.lovelysilvia.com
Okay now this has my name written all over it. I will definitely be making these for “Santa” this year!
Those look yummy! My twin granddaughters will have so much fun making these sandwiches for Santa.
Oh YUM!!! I love me some Fluffernutter and these little sandwiches look amazing!! Great recipe!!
Oh my goodness. This brings me back to my childhood. We smeared marshmallow fluff on everything. We will definitely be making these at my house, but I do not think they will last for Santa.
Mmm, these are so delicious. I am bookmarking this to make on the weekend.
Wow those look so cute and good. I bet Santa will love them , maybe we should make some for him as well.
These look TASTY! I love flutter nutter anything! 😀
That looks so delicious and tasty. I love marshmallow fluff and these are so easy to make!
These look so delicious and easy to make. They will be perfect for the Holidays.
These look great! I love how simple they’re to make as well. I need to have my girls make some of them for Santa. Thanks for sharing!
You had me a Nilla wafers. This dessert looks amazing.
These sandwich cookies are just too cute! My family is crazy for marshmallow fluff so I am sure they would love these.
They look so cute! I know Santa will love them! I can’t wait to make them!
These look so good and my kids would love making them!
Can I be your Santa? Those look a lot better than the carrots we leave for him :p
Yummy, those look and sound absolutely scrumptious. We have a lot of fun making cookies for Santa. I’ll have to let the grand kids help me try these this year.